| Number: | Name | Time | Year | Grade | Location |
| 1 | Annie Cekada | 18:21 | 2010 | Sophomore | Otterbein |
| 2 | Jenna Parlette | 18:39 | 2012 | Sophomore | Wilmington |
| 3 | Brittany Wolf | 18:47 | 2000 | Senior | Washington |
| 4 | Kara Braun | 18:54 | 2000 | Sophomre | Washington |
| 5 | Jessica Unger | 19:03 | 1999 | Junior | Ohio Northern |
| 6 | Sarah Matthews | 19:10 | 2007 | Sophomore | Calvin |
| 7 | Tricia Steffen | 19:18 | 2013 | Junior | Wilmington |
| 8 | Kelsey Stief | 19:25 | 2010 | Senior | Cedarville |
| 9 | Sydney Yontz | 19:25 | 2019 | Freshman | Wilmington |
| 10 | Nicole Tabet | 19:26 | 1995 | Junior | Cedarville |
| 11 | Brittany Gibbons | 19:27 | 2011 | Junior | Franklin |
| 12 | Milena Wahl | 19:32 | 2019 | Freshman | Wilmington |
| 13 | Jamey Landis | 19:35 | 2000 | Freshman | Washington |
| 14 | Kelly McKinley | 19:46 | 1994 | Sophomore | Anderson |
| 15 | Karlee Michel | 19:48 | 2010 | Sophomore | Otterbein |
| 16 | Stephanie Hamm | 19:51 | 1998 | Sophomore | Franklin |
| 17 | Rachel Scott | 19:52 | 1995 | Freshman | Cedarville |
| 18 | Jessie Irelan | 19:52 | 2001 | Freshman | Wilmington |
| 19 | Tiffany Myers | 19:55 | 2004 | Senior | Alma |
| 20 | Colleen Romeo | 19:57 | 2011 | Senior | Cedarville |
| 21 | Lillian Bunn | 19:59 | 2010 | Senior | Otterbein |
| 22 | Sarah Moran | 20:05 | 1999 | Freshman | Ohio Northern |
| 23 | K. Liederbach | 20:05 | 2007 | Senior | Louisville |
| 24 | Kasey Hoover | 20:10 | 1997 | Freshman | Heidelberg |
| 25 | Kylie Watson | 20:10 | 2014 | Freshman | Cedarville |
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Mitch Blankespoor, director of athletic communications, at mitch_blankespoor@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - Nov. 29, 2021