| Number | Name | Time | Year | Grade | Location |
| 1 | Simon Heys | 23:46.7 | 2023 | Senior | Norton, Ohio |
| 2 | Simon Heys | 23:57.0 | 2021 | Sophomore | Louisville, Ky. |
| 3 | Simon Heys | 24:11.4 | 2021 | Sophomore | Louisville, Ky. |
| 4 | Simon Heys | 24:15.8 | 2023 | Senior | Ada, Ohio |
| 5 | Simon Heys | 24:22.9 | 2022 | Junior | Cedarville, Ohio |
| 6 | Simon Heys | 24:23.0 | 2022 | Junior | Holland, Mich. |
| 7 | Simon Heys | 24:23.8 | 2023 | Senior | Wilmington, Ohio |
| 8 | Simon Heys | 24:27.4 | 2023 | Senior | Cedarville, Ohio |
| 9 | Noah Tobin | 24:28.7 | 2023 | Junior | Norton, Ohio |
| 10 | Simon Heys | 24:29.9 | 2022 | Junior | Wilmington, Ohio |
| 11 | Noah Tobin | 24:35.6 | 2022 | Sophomore | Holland, Mich. |
| 12 | Simon Heys | 24:35.9 | 2022 | Junior | Lansing, Mich. |
| 13 | Simon Heys | 24:40.4 | 2021 | Sophomore | Shelbyville, Ind. |
| 14 | George Rickett | 24:43.5 | 2022 | Senior | Holland, Mich. |
| 15 | Simon Heys | 24:44.9 | 2021 | Sophomore | Wilmington, Ohio |
| 16 | Simon Heys | 24:46.1 | 2023 | Senior | Newville, Pa. |
| 17 | Noah Tobin | 24:53.3 | 2022 | Sophomore | Cedarville, Ohio |
| 18 | George Rickett | 24:54.0 | 2022 | Senior | Wilmington, Ohio |
| 19 | Noah Tobin | 24:58.2 | 2022 | Sophomore | Wilmington, Ohio |
| 20 | Noah Tobin | 24:59.4 | 2023 | Junior | Tiffin, Ohio |
| 21 | Noah Tobin | 24:59.7 | 2022 | Sophomore | Tiffin, Ohio |
| 22 | Simon Heys | 25:03.5 | 2021 | Sophomore | Shelbyville, Ind. |
| 23 | Noah Tobin | 25:03.8 | 2022 | Sophomore | Lansing, Mich. |
| 24 | Simon Heys | 25:04.4 | 2023 | Senior | Newville, Pa. |
| 25 | Tate Yoder | 25:07.4 | 2023 | Sophomore | Norton, Ohio |
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last Updated Dec. 4, 2023*