| Year | Round | Opponent | Location | Result | Coach |
| 1983 | Quarterfinals | William Jewel (Mo.) | Liberty, Mo. | Loss, 51-7 | Bill Ramseyer |
| 1982 | Quarterfinals | Westminster (Pa.) | Wilmington, Ohio | Loss, 14-7 | Bill Ramseyer |
| 1980 | Quarterfinals | Hanover | Wilmington, Ohio | Win, 56-49 (4OT) | Bill Ramseyer |
| 1980 | Semifinals | William Jewel (Mo.) | Liberty, Mo. | Win, 31-17 | Bill Ramseyer |
| 1980 | National Championship | Pacific Lutheran | Tacoma, Wash. | Loss, 38-10 | Bill Ramseyer |
* the NAIA Tournament was comprised of eight teams during the 1980s
Wilmington has made three appearances in the NAIA Division II Tournament and holds a 2-3 record in tournament play.
Wilmington is 1-2 in quarterfinal games, 1-0 in semifinals games and 0-1 in national championship games.
Wilmington is 1-1 in home games and 1-2 in road contests.
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - July 11, 2018