| Year | Name | Honor | Conference |
| 2023 | Tyler Shaneyfelt | First Team | OAC |
| 2023 | Aaron Boster | Second Team | OAC |
| 2023 | Zach Shepherd | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2022 | Tyler Shaneyfelt | Second Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Caleb Scott | Second Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Zach Christensen | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2022 | Jared Lammert | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 | Jesse Reliford | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 | Tyler Shaneyfelt | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2019 | Gage Bley | First Team | OAC |
| 2019 | Antonio Miller | Second Team | OAC |
| 2019 | Nick Silvis | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2018 | Joshua Chua | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2017 | Joshua Chua | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2016 | Corey Walker | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2015 | Clay Cleaver | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2014 | Brandon Arehart | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2013 | Hunter Justus | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2012 | Hunter Justus | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Dan Roncolato | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Bruce Dunlap | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2010 | Dan Roncolato | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2009 | Bruce Dunlap | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2008 | Jason Iles | Second Team | OAC |
| 2007 | Jason Iles | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Greg Krieger | Second Team | OAC |
| 2006 | Ben Buehner | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Taylor Clark | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Tony Haley | Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2005 | Mike Cafarella | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Ben Butler | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Ben Buehner | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Jamison George | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Greg Krieger | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Brent Bird | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2004 | Chad Abbott | Second Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Ben Buehner | Second Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Aaron Lawson | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | Aaron Lawson | First Team | OAC |
| 2003 | Justin Evans | First Team | OAC |
| 2003 | Chad Abbott | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | Derek Wellington | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2002 | Justin Evans | First Team | OAC |
| 2002 | Alan Ledford | First Team | OAC |
| 2002 | Aaron Lawson | Second Team | OAC |
| 2002 | Josh Martin | Honorable Mention | OAC |
Wilmington as a member of NCAA Division III - six First Teamers, 12 Second Teamers and 25 Honorable Mention.
Wilmington in the OAC (Ohio Athletic Conference) - one Coach of the Year, six First Teamers, 10 Second Teamers and 23 Honorable Mentions.
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Mitch Blankespoor, director of athletic communications, at mitch_blankespoor@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - May 17, 2023