| Year | Name | Honor | Conference |
| 2023 | Thomas Grimes | Second Team | OAC |
| 2023 | William Jansson | Third Team | OAC |
| 2023 | Andre Hagborg | Third Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Elorm Dogbey | First Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Michael Owusu | First Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Casey Miller | Second Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Jeffry Vasquez | Second Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Yusef Muqtadir | Third Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Grany Murray | Third Team | OAC |
| 2022 | Thomas Grimes | Third Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Alex Van der Sluijs | Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Yusef Muqtadir | First Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Jeffry Vasquez | Second Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Elorm Dogbey | Second Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Brady Shapiro | Second Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Michael Owusu | Third Team | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Felix Maurer | Third Team | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Elorm Dogbey | Forward of the Year | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Zach Burgmeier | Defender of the Year | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Elorm Dogbey | First Team | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Zach Burgmeier | First Team | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Ian Molfenter | First Team | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Yusef Muqtadir | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 spring | Brad Shapiro | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2019 | Ian Molfenter | First Team | OAC |
| 2019 | Zach Burgmeier | Second Team | OAC |
| 2019 | Thompson Birch | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2018 | Niklas Martensson | First Team | OAC |
| 2018 | Thompson Birch | Second Team | OAC |
| 2017 | Bud Lewis | Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2017 | Niklas Martenson | Second Team | OAC |
| 2016 | Nils Asteberg | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2015 | Nick Toney | Second Team | OAC |
| 2014 | Martin Holmquist | First Team | OAC |
| 2014 | Nick Toney | Second Team | OAC |
| 2014 | Daniel Wicks | Second Team | OAC |
| 2013 | Martin Holmquist | Defender of the Year | OAC |
| 2013 | Martin Holmquist | First Team | OAC |
| 2013 | Anton Niklasson | Second Team | OAC |
| 2013 | Nick Toney | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2013 | Markus Tornberg | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2013 | Daniel Wicks | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2012 | Martin Holmquist | First Team | OAC |
| 2012 | Henrik Hornnaess | First Team | OAC |
| 2012 | Daniel Wicks | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Armin Fejzic | First Team | OAC |
| 2011 | Max Eurenius | Second Team | OAC |
| 2011 | Erik Hammar | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Martin Holmquist | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2010 | Emil Nordstrom | Second Team | OAC |
| 2010 | Zach Owsley | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2010 | Antonio Trujillo | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2009 | Michael Kiszkiel | Second Team | OAC |
| 2009 | Daniel Givens | Second Team | OAC |
| 2009 | Emil Nordstrom | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2009 | Nick Kinder | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2008 | Aaron Slusher | Goalkeeper of the Year | OAC |
| 2008 | Aaron Slusher | First Team | OAC |
| 2008 | Thomas Keane | Second Team | OAC |
| 2008 | Romma Sharifi | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2007 | J.T. Pitstick | Second Team | OAC |
| 2007 | Aaron Slusher | Second Team | OAC |
| 2007 | Anthony Montgomery | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2007 | Matt Hoenie | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Alex Van der Sluijs | Forward of the Year | OAC |
| 2006 | Alex Van der Sluijs | First Team | OAC |
| 2006 | Chad Garman | Second Team | OAC |
| 2006 | Eric Shultz | Second Team | OAC |
| 2006 | J.R. Barnhart | Honorable Menetion | OAC |
| 2006 | J.T. Pitstick | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Aaron Slusher | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Alex Van der Sluijs | First Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Justin Saylor | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Jason Glover | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Chad Garman | Second Team | OAC |
| 2005 | Oskar Johansson | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Phil Walter | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2004 | Bud Lewis | Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2004 | Chad Garman | Midfielder of the Year | OAC |
| 2004 | Alex Van der Sluijs | Forward of the Year | OAC |
| 2004 | Justin Saylor | Goalkeeper of the Year | OAC |
| 2004 | Justin Saylor | First Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Eric Shultz | First Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Chad Garman | First Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Alex Van der Sluijs | First Team | OAC |
| 2004 | Ross Garber | Second Team | OAC |
| 2004 | David Benedict | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | David Benedict | First Team | OAC |
| 2003 | Eric Shultz | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | Chad Garman | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2002 | Mark Kinsel | Second Team | OAC |
| 2002 | Dave Satterwhite | Second Team | OAC |
| 2002 | Chris Darby | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2001 | Billy Gronostaj | Goalkeeper of the Year | OAC |
| 2001 | Billy Bronostaj | First Team | OAC |
| 2001 | Bjorn Lidman | First Team | OAC |
| 2001 | Scott Lower | First Team | OAC |
| 2000 | Jonas Svensson | First Team | OAC |
| 2000 | Andy Szucs | First Team | OAC |
| 2000 | Bjorn Lidman | Second Team | OAC |
| 2000 | Tevis Foreman | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2000 | Scott Lower | Honorable Mention | OAC |
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - Nov. 17, 2023*