| Year | Round | Opponent | Location | Result | Coach |
| 2004 | First Round | Bye | N/A | N/A | Bud Lewis |
| 2004 | Second Round | Wheaton (Ill.) | Wilmington, Ohio | Win, 2-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 2004 | Regional Semifinal ("Sweet 16") | Wartburg | Wilmington, Ohio | Loss, 1-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 2001^ | First Round | Sewanee | Wilmington, Ohio | Win, 2-1 | Bud Lewis |
| 2001^ | Regional Semifinal | Roanoke | Greensboro, N.C. | Loss, 1-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 2000^ | First Round | Kalamazoo | Wilmington, Ohio | Win, 5-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 2000^ | Regional Semifinal | John Carroll | Delaware, Ohio | Win, 4-2 | Bud Lewis |
| 2000^ | Regional Final ("Sweet 16") | Ohio Wesleyan | Delaware, Ohio | Loss, 1-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 1999^ | Regional Semifinal | Wis.-Whitewater | Westerville, Ohio | Loss, 1-0 (OT) | Bud Lewis |
| 1996! | Regional Semifinal | Hope | Gambier, Ohio | Win, 2-0 | Bud Lewis |
| 1996! | Regional Final ("Sweet 16") | Kenyon | Gambier, Ohio | Loss, 3-2 | Bud Lewis |
^ denotes when the NCAA Division III Tournament played an opening round, two rounds of regionals, quarterfinals and final four.
! denotes a 32-team NCAA Division III Tournament field (1990-96)
Wilmington has made five appearances in the NCAA Division III Tournament and holds a 5-5 record in tournament play with two three byes.
Wilmington is 2-0 in the first round and 1-0 in the second round of the tournament with one first-round bye.
Wilmington is 2-3 in regional semifinal games and 0-1 in regional final contests.
Wilmington is 3-1 in home games, 0-2 on the road and 2-2 in neutral-site contests.
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - June 14, 2018*