| Year | Name | Honor | Conference |
| 2023 | Hayden Thomas | Assistant Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2023 | Lathan Jones | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2023 | Saa'lih Muhammed | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2023 | Derek Larimer | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2023 | Nehemiah Jenkins | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2023 | Steven Salyer | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2023 | Kaleb Easley | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2022 | Itika Wynn Jr. | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2022 | Ace Taylor | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2022 | Brandon Lemley | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2022 | Jarod Lee | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2022 | Zac Schmidt | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Itika Wynn Jr. | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Tavion Bryant | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Tre'Quez Parks | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Brandon Weaver | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 fall | Ace Taylor | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Corey Fillipovich | Assistant Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Tavion Bryant | Gene Slaughter Award (Most Valuable Linebacker) | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Itika Wynn Jr. | All-OAC Offense | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Caleb Deaver | All-OAC Offense | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Tavion Bryant | All-OAC Defense | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Tre'Quez Parks | All-OAC Defense | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Brandon Weaver | All-OAC Defense | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Jarod Lee | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Xzerious Stinnett | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2021 spring ^ | Ace Taylor | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2019 | Itika Wynn Jr | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2019 | Luke Richardson | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2019 | Tavion Bryant | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2019 | Ameer Jackson | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2019 | Tre'Quez Parks | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2019 | Nick Moore | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2018 | DJ Chambers | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2018 | Tre'Quez Parks | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2018 | Luke Richardson | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2018 | Saul Boysel | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2018 | Kyle Ackley | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2017 | PJ Meyer | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2017 | Luke Creditt | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2017 | David Henry | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2017 | Eric Flynn | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2017 | Sterling Clark | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2017 | CJ Thompson | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2016 | CJ Thompson | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2016 | PJ Meyer | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2016 | Darren Milligan | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2015 | Justin Lee | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2015 | David Henry | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2015 | Nick Williams | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2015 | Amari Bryant | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2014 | Nick Williams | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2014 | Chase Manica | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2013 | Jefremy Duncan | Ed Sherman Award (Most Valuable Receiver) | OAC |
| 2013 | Jeremy Duncan | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2013 | Aaron Day | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2013 | Donnie Ary | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2013 | Brandon Arehart | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2012 | Chris Ferguson | Honorabe Mention | OAC |
| 2012 | Max Gabbard | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Brett McEvoy | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2011 | Donnie Ary | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2010 | Bryce Martin | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2010 | Randy Swain | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2010 | TJ Burbridge | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2010 | Cody Hamilton | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2009 | Bryce Martin | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2009 | Luke Green | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2009 | Chris Medley | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2008 | Barry Wulf | Coach of the Year | OAC |
| 2008 | Brandon Hiatt | SecondTeam Offense | OAC |
| 2008 | Wes Anders | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2008 | Kenny Marsh | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2008 | Chris Medley | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2008 | Marque Jones | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2008 | TJ Burbridge | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2007 | Marque Jones | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2007 | Wes Anders | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2007 | Mac Otte | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2007 | Brent Scherz | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2007 | Brandon Hiatt | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2007 | Chad Adams | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Chad Otte | Lee J. Tressel Award (Most Valuable Defensive Back) | OAC |
| 2006 | Chad Otte | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2006 | Taylor Clark | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2006 | Brandon Hiatt | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2006 | Chad Adams | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Brandon Tisdale | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2005 | Deon Short | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2005 | Cory Norvell | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2005 | Marcus Hefner | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2005 | Jeff Jenkins | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2004 | Brandon Tisdale | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2004 | Deon Short | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2004 | Cory Norvell | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2004 | Marcus Hefner | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2004 | Jeff Jenkins | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | Brandon Tisdale | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2003 | Bryan Kennedy | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2003 | Abe Lawson | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2003 | Greg Morrow | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2002 | Greg Liggens | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2002 | Abe Lawson | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2002 | Brandon Tisdale | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2002 | Will Isaac | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2002 | Richard Scales | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2001 | Jonathan Cain | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2001 | Jake Pence | First Team Offense | OAC |
| 2001 | Greg Liggens | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2001 | Anthony Robinson | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2001 | Antonio Broadnax | First Team Defense | OAC |
| 2001 | Will Isaac | Second Team Offense | OAC |
| 2001 | Brandon Tisdale | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2001 | Wallace Morris | Second Team Defense | OAC |
| 2001 | Ryan Alspaugh | Honorable Mention | OAC |
| 2001 | Shane Wellman | Honorable Mention | OAC |
Wilmington as a member of the Ohio Athletic Conference (since 2000) - eight First Team Offensive Honorees, 10 First Team Defensive Honorees, 17 Second Team Offensive Honorees, 22 Second Team Defensive Honorees and 46 Honorable Mentions.
^ denotes COVID-19 season where just one All-OAC team was named...counted as First Team Honorees above
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - Nov. 21, 2023*