| Name | Points | Years |
| Fletcher Yates | 1,953 | 1971-75 |
| Bill Baugherty | 1,673 | 1982-86 |
| Malcolm Heard II | 1,577 | 2009-13 |
| Tim Dicke | 1,562 | 1987-91 |
| Jack Harner | 1,390 | 1954-58 |
| Kevin Blanton | 1,388 | 1981-85 |
| Christian Jones | 1,379 | 2014-18 |
| Walt Hobble | 1,339 | 1947-51 |
| Jeffery Mansfield | 1,326 | 2021-22 |
| Tom Vessely | 1,283 | 1967-71 |
| Pat Stevens | 1,280 | 1985-89 |
| Chris Sonneman | 1,265 | 1988-92 |
| Eric Sears | 1,252 | 1989-93 |
| Brandon Rogers | 1,245 | 2006-10 |
| Rex Taylor | 1,225 | 1960-64 |
| Doug Frey | 1,205 | 1979-83 |
| Cal Zigler | 1.171 | 1923-27 |
| Tyler White | 1,161 | 2007-11 |
| Chris Mitchell | 1,114 | 1988-92 |
| Antonio Bowman | 1,107 | 2008-12 |
| Dan Shardo | 1,105 | 1997-01 |
| Brandon Candella | 1,084 | 2009-13 |
| Lee Berry | 1,070 | 1978-80 |
| Craig Hall | 1,050 | 1985-89 |
| Roger Reveal | 1,047 | 1960-64 |
| Jay Slouffman | 1,023 | 1985-89 |
| David Guy | 1,013 | 2001-05 |
| Dan Simpson | 1,000 | 1949-53 |
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
*Last updated - March 7th, 2024*