| Year | Conference | Seed | Round | Opponent | Result | Coach |
| 2023 | OAC | No. 6 | First Round | No. 3 Ohio Northern | Loss, 1-0 | Nick Kinder |
| 2021 (spring) ^ | OAC | No. 4 | First Round | No. 5 Baldwin Wallace | Win, 1-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2021 (spring) ^ | OAC | No. 4 | Semifinals | No. 1 Otterbein | Loss, 5-1 | Steve Spirk |
| 2019 | OAC | No. 6 | First Round | No. 3 Otterbein | Loss, 2-1 (2OT) | Steve Spirk |
| 2015 | OAC | No. 5 | First Round | No. 4 Baldwin Wallace | Loss, 4-1 | Steve Spirk |
| 2012 | OAC | No. 5 | First Round | No. 4 Ohio Northern | Loss, 2-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2011 | OAC | No. 6 | First Round | No. 3 Capital | Loss, 4-1 | Steve Spirk |
| 2010 | OAC | No. 5 | First Round | No. 4 John Carroll | Tie 0-0 (PK Win) | Steve Spirk |
| 2010 | OAC | No. 5 | Semifinals | No. 1 Otterbein | Loss, 5-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2009 | OAC | No. 4 | First Round | No. 5 Capital | Loss, 1-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2008 | OAC | No. 3 | First Round | No. 6 Baldwin Wallace | Win, 3-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2008 | OAC | No. 3 | Semifinals | No. 2 Ohio Northern | Loss, 4-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2007 | OAC | No. 5 | First Round | No. 4 Baldwin Wallace | Win, 2-1 | Steve Spirk |
| 2007 | OAC | No. 5 | Semifinals | No. 1 Ohio Northern | Loss, 2-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2006 | OAC | No. 4 | Semifinals | No. 1 Otterbein | Loss, 3-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2004 | OAC | No. 3 | Semifinals | No. 2 Otterbein | Loss, 3-1 | Steve Spirk |
| 2003 | OAC | No. 1 | Semifinals | No. 4 Mount Union | Win, 5-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2003 | OAC | No. 1 | Championship | No. 2 Otterbein | Win, 1-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2002 | OAC | No. 3 | Semifinals | No. 2 John Carroll | Tie, 1-1 (PK Win) | Steve Spirk |
| 2002 | OAC | No. 3 | Championship | No. 1 Otterbein | Win, 1-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2001 | OAC | No. 1 | Semifinals | No. 4 Muskingum | Win, 2-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2001 | OAC | No. 1 | Championship | No. 3 John Carroll | Loss, 2-1 (3OT) | Steve Spirk |
| 2000 | OAC | No. 2 | Semifinals | No. 3 Capital | Win, 1-0 | Steve Spirk |
| 2000 | OAC | No. 2 | Championship | No. 1 John Carroll | Win, 1-0 (3OT) | Steve Spirk |
*Prior to 2007, the OAC Tournament took only the top four teams. Since then, the tournament fields the top six teams with the No. 1 and No. 2 seeds receiving first round byes.
Wilmington in the OAC Tournament - 9-13-2 overall, 3-6-1 in the first round, 3-6-1 in the semifinals and 3-1 in championship games.
Wilmington's record as each seed - No. 1 (3-1), No. 2 (2-0), No. 3 (2-2-1), No. 4 (1-3), No. 5 (1-4-1), No. 6 (0-3).
Wilmington's record against each opponent - Baldwin Wallace (3-1), Capital (1-2), Heidelberg (0-0), John Carroll (1-1-2), Marietta (0-0), Mount Union (1-0), Muskingum (1-0), Ohio Northern (0-4), Otterbein (2-5).
*The office of athletic communications makes a concerted effort to keep these records accurate. If you have information that could assist this page, please contact Michael Pagano, Director of Athletic Communications, at michael.pagano@wilmington.edu.
^ denotes shortened season due to COVID-19 pandemic
*Last updated - December 7, 2023*